Anti-fraud Technology

Organized Chaos

Professional insurance fraud rings are sapping billions from the P&C insurance sector. Insurers are fighting back with sophisticated technology. 
By: | February 19, 2015 • 9 min read
02012015_38_Fraud_fake _ PB

It was like something out of a Hollywood crime drama. The gang’s operations were meticulously planned and ran like clockwork. The cartel was managed by a team of shady Russian characters. Money flowed like a river.

But it wasn’t drug money. And it wasn’t from gun running or human trafficking. It was the spoils of ill-gotten insurance money from staged car crashes throughout New York City.

Advertisement




In 2013, an extended sting operation — involving the NYPD, the FBI, and the National Insurance Crime Bureau (NICB) — uncovered more than $400 million in fake injury claims from both real and set-up crashes in NYC.

The sting revealed dozens of key players, including doctors and lawyers on the take, a supporting cast of thousands of fake patients and patient recruiters, 100 phony medical clinics, and numerous crooked testing labs, medical-supply firms, and billing firms.

While most organized crime rings aren’t quite as ambitious as this one, they’re typically just as complex and also just as lucrative for the players involved.

Sophisticated professional fraud rings are actively bilking insurance companies of billions in no-fault auto/PIP, health care coverage, and workers’ comp claims fraud. Most operate using multiple false identities, targeting multiple organizations. They often recruit or “groom” insiders to assist in their schemes.

“These large rings, they’re highly adaptive,” said Tom Mulvey, assistant vice president, claim and SIU services, for ISO, an operating unit of Verisk. “It’s aggressive and it’s well camouflaged. These are dedicated perpetrators. They cross state lines and they spread their habit across a multitude of carriers. They’re not one-stop shopping — they make sure that everyone’s in play.

Tom Mulvey, assistant vice president, claim and SIU services, ISO

Tom Mulvey, assistant vice president, claim and SIU services, ISO

“Some of the camouflage they use is using numerous business names and locations,” he continued.

“They really work to cover their tracks; they artificially disburse their identities, they segment their volume. So rather than doing business with a carrier as a B2B, they [manipulate] their profile by operating as multiple businesses behind many identities.”

They’re also incredibly expensive to fight. But the cost of ignoring them is even higher.

According to information compiled by organizations such as the Insurance Information Institute (III) and the Coalition Against Insurance Fraud, property and casualty insurance fraud costs insurers approximately $33 billion a year — at least 10 percent of all losses, according to NICB.

But other organizations, including the FBI, place that number even higher, upwards of $40 billion.

Far from being a victimless crime, every policyholder foots the bill for this robust criminal activity, which continues to grow. NICB reports that the number of questionable insurance claims rose by 16 percent from 2011 to 2012.

The old wisdom was that a certain amount of fraud was simply a cost of doing business, and many insurers felt that a more proactive approach ran the risk of alienating good policyholders by investigating and delaying legitimate claims.

That strategy backfired, and fraudsters grew bolder and greedier. At some point, though, the costs rose so high that insurers realized they had to fight back.

Most insurance companies now employ special investigative units (SIUs), which utilize a variety of strategies and tools to detect and prevent fraud, with technology at the core of those tools.

A 2012 survey by the Coalition Against Insurance Fraud indicated that 95 percent of insurance companies are now using some form of anti-fraud technology. But this development is still fairly new — only half of survey respondents said they have been using this technology for more than five years, many had only been using it for two years at the time of the survey.

Advertisement




As insurers work to establish and improve their anti-fraud programs, they face questions about which technologies to invest in. There’s no single magic-bullet tool that will cover every base.

Experts say that a multi-layered program must be in place in order to make any kind of substantive difference.

Finding Connections

The most common form of anti-fraud technology involves the use of business rules, or red flags. These systems test each transaction against a predefined set of algorithms or business rules to detect known types of fraud based on specific patterns of activity.

A rule might flag a claim for further investigation if it exceeds a certain dollar amount, occurs too soon after a policy is written, involves no witnesses, or if the claimant has submitted a high number of claims in the past year, for example.

The downside is that professional fraudsters are well aware of the various rules and thresholds typically used, and are skilled at flying just below the radar. They also know that flagged claims are likely to be subject to a database search such as ISO’s ClaimSearch, so they’ve even developed strategies to hoodwink the search engines.

“For every new technology, the thieves or fraudsters are going to be enthusiastically looking for ways to defeat the technologies,” said Jim Schweitzer, senior vice president and COO of NICB.

“The key is to find out who they are and what they’re doing before they get really good and begin to cause real harm to the industry and the general public.” — Tom Mulvey, assistant vice president, claim and SIU services, ISO

One attempt to get ahead of the thieves involves new software solutions called link analysis systems. These systems allow for a broader view than a straight database search, and can help identify the connections between players in a fraud ring, even when efforts have been made to blur those connections.

“Let’s say two vehicles have an accident,” said Stuart Rose, global insurance marketing director for SAS, a technology company involved in this area.

“You may have three or four different passengers involved. Two get injured and they go off to one medical provider. In six months’ time another accident occurs.

“It’s completely separate when looked at in isolation, but when you start to look at them combined, you start to see that the same insured was involved in both accidents. It may have been different vehicles.

“He may have been a passenger in both of them. But he’s going to the same medical provider. Another six months and the same thing happens.”

You start to see the same key person involved in all of these claims, said Rose.

Stuart Rose, global insurance marketing director, SAS

Stuart Rose, global insurance marketing director, SAS

“It’s a little like how LinkedIn or Facebook works. You start seeing all of those connections and how many degrees of separation there are from the insured.”

There are several key advantages to link analysis software. It can spot easily missed connections, such as multiple claim payments going to the same bank account, even when they’re all under different names. It can also catch the minor detail variations that fraud rings use to avoid detection.

“The payee, instead of Stuart Rose, may be Stuart Ross, or maybe even Steve Rose. They manipulate the ID just a little bit,” Rose said.

The Power of Volume

The more data that could be shared across the industry, the easier it would be for insurers to connect the dots. But insurers have been resistant to engage in any type of substantive data sharing due to privacy concerns.

Emerging tools on the market are a step in the right direction. ISO has been developing ClaimSearch DNA, an advanced link analysis program that works in conjunction with its existing ClaimSearch database. That allows users the benefits of link analysis beyond their own organizations’ data.

Advertisement




“It’s been built to uncover the camouflage and graphically demonstrate connections of entities through an ISO visual analysis tool called NetMap,” said ISO’s Mulvey. “It really unravels the cover-up that conspirators work so hard to develop.”

The DNA system works on top of the ClaimSearch database, which contains nearly a billion loss records. It is designed to search constantly for anomalies and associations in the database.

“The proactive nature of this approach really lends itself to operate as an early warning system using the broad scale of industry loss data,” said Mulvey. “So rather than waiting for an individual carrier to recognize suspicious activity, this will speed things up and recognize the emerging group very early in its development. That time to detection is very important.”

“Once you put those safeguards in place, it’s amazing how quickly those fraudsters disappear. It’s not always about catching them,” said Rose. “It’s more about deterring them or deflecting them.” — Stuart Rose, global insurance marketing director, SAS

Professional fraud rings are a lot like any other business, in that they need to go through a development stage, getting the right people and resources in place. In the meantime, these startup rings will be orchestrating claims to produce cash flow.

“The key is to find out who they are and what they’re doing before they get really good and begin to cause real harm to the industry and the general public,” said Mulvey.

02012015_38_Fraud_chartTo that end, some insurers have begun using predictive modeling to shorten that time to detection. Chubb reports a high degree of success using predictive models on its casualty claims for the past eight years.

Chubb’s Don Siegrist, vice president, home office SIU and recovery manager, said that the company has built models based on the attributes of its successfully closed SIU cases.

The models have yielded a high success rate in identifying the claims that should be referred to the SIU, and are able to do so weeks or sometimes months before adjusters might have been able to flag them — sometimes in a matter of days.

“What it does is, it changes the tone of the investigation,” said Siegrist.

“The evidence is fresher. People’s minds are fresher; they still remember what occurred in the incident. The evidence that’s there is more available and nothing’s been changed. It makes for a much more powerful investigation.”

Supporting Tools

Text mining is another technology that should be a key part of a fraud-fighting program. Much of what fraud investigators have to work with is unstructured data — the information that doesn’t fit into neat little boxes on a form or in a database field, such as doctors’ notes, police reports or adjusters’ notes.

“You’ll start to see things like maybe the same phrase is being used by multiple different claimants,” said Rose of SAS.

“That’s because they’ve been taught by these fraud rings to know exactly what to say to the insurance companies.”

“For every new technology, the thieves or fraudsters are going to be enthusiastically looking for ways to defeat the technologies,” — Jim Schweitzer, senior vice president and COO, NICB.

Social media analysis is sometimes part of the mix, although its use may be more limited in its effectiveness against professional fraud. Still, in a case like the NYC ring with thousands of minor players, it could have been used to investigate the many “patients” involved, some of whom undoubtedly failed to keep up the pretense of their injuries. Some may have even boasted about the scam.

“It’s amazing what people are willing to brag about,” said NICB’s Schweitzer.

Advertisement




“Law enforcement every day are solving cases where the individuals involved talked about [their crimes] with friends on Facebook or Twitter or some other social media. There is that human need for attention … letting people know, ‘Hey, I got away with this.’ It’s crazy but it’s true.”

Of course, none of these tools can wholly prevent fraud, Rose cautioned. But they can help insurers spot trends sooner, develop strategies based on those trends and get critical information to adjusters early on.

“Once you put those safeguards in place, it’s amazing how quickly those fraudsters disappear. It’s not always about catching them,” said Rose. “It’s more about deterring them or deflecting them.”

Michelle Kerr is associate editor of Risk & Insurance. She can be reached at mkerr@lrp.com
Share this article:

Infographic: The Risk List

Top 6 Risks of U.S. Companies Working Globally

Working overseas poses countless risks for employers and employees. Presented by Travelers.
By: | December 10, 2014 • 2 min read
RiskList_Dec RiskList_Dec RiskList_Dec

The Risk List is presented by:

RiskList_Dec RiskList_Dec RiskList_Dec RiskList_Dec



The R&I Editorial Team may be reached at riskletters@lrp.com.
Share this article:

Sponsored: Aspen Insurance

A Modern Claims Philosophy: Proactive and Integrated

Aspen Insurance views the expertise and data of their claims professionals as a valuable asset.
By: | March 2, 2015 • 4 min read
SponsoredContent_Aspen

According to some experts, “The best claim is the one that never happens.”

But is that even remotely realistic?

Experienced risk professionals know that in the real world, claims and losses are inevitable. After all, it’s called Risk Management, not Risk Avoidance.

And while no one likes losses, there are rich lessons to be gleaned from the claims management process. Through careful tracking and analysis of losses, risk professionals spot gaps in their risk control programs and identify new or emerging risks.

Aspen Insurance embraces this philosophy by viewing the data and expertise of their claims operation as a valuable asset. Unlike more traditional carriers, Aspen Insurance integrates their claims professionals into all of their client work – from the initial risk assessment and underwriting process through ongoing risk management consulting and loss control.

This proactive and integrated approach results in meaningful reductions to the frequency and severity of client losses. But when the inevitable does happen, Aspen Insurance claims professionals utilize their established understanding of client risks and operations to produce some truly amazing solutions.

“I worked at several of the most well known and respected insurance companies in my many years as a claims executive. But few of them utilize an approach that is as innovative as Aspen Insurance,” said Stephen Perrella, senior vice president, casualty claims, at Aspen Insurance.

SponsoredContent_Aspen“We do a lot of trending and data analysis to provide as much information as possible to our clients. Our analytics can help clients improve upon their own risk management procedures.”
— Stephen Perrella, Senior Vice President, Casualty Claims, Aspen Insurance

Utilizing claims expertise to improve underwriting

Acting as adviser and advocate, Aspen integrates the entire process under a coverage coordinator who ensures that the underwriters, claims and insureds agree on consistent, clear definitions and protocols. With claims professionals involved in the initial account review and the development of form language, Aspen’s underwriters have a full sense of risks so they can provide more specific and meaningful coverage, and identify risks and exclusions that the underwriter might not consider during a routine underwriting process.

“Most insurers don’t ever want to talk about claims and underwriting in the same sentence,” said Perrella. “That archaic view can potentially hurt the insurance company as well as their business partners.”
SponsoredContent_AspenSponsoredContent_AspenAspen Insurance considered a company working on a large bridge refurbishment project on the West Coast as a potential insured, posing the array of generally anticipated construction-related risks. During underwriting, its claims managers discovered there was a large oil storage facility underneath the bridge. If a worker didn’t properly tether his or her tools, or a piece of steel fell onto a tank and fractured it, the consequences would be severe. Shutting down a widely used waterway channel for an oil cleanup would be devastating. The business interruption claims alone would be astronomical.

“We narrowed the opportunity for possible claims that the underwriter was unaware existed at the outset,” said Perrella.

SponsoredContent_Aspen

Risk management improved

Claims professionals help Aspen Insurance’s clients with their risk management programs. When data analysis reveals high numbers of claims in a particular area, Aspen readily shares that information with the client. The Aspen team then works with the client to determine if there are better ways to handle certain processes.

“We do a lot of trending and data analysis to provide as much information as possible to our clients,” said Perrella. “Our analytics can help clients improve upon their own risk management procedures.”
SponsoredContent_Aspen
SponsoredContent_AspenFor a large restaurant-and-entertainment group with locations in New York and Las Vegas, Aspen’s consultative approach has been critical. After meeting with risk managers and using analytics to study trends in the client’s portfolio, Aspen learned that the sheer size and volume of customers at each location led to disparate profiles of patron injuries.

Specifically, the organization had a high number of glass-related incidents across its multiple venues. So Aspen’s claims and underwriting professionals helped the organization implement new reporting protocols and risk-prevention strategies that led to a significant drop in glass-related claims over the following two years. Where one location would experience a disproportionate level of security assault or slip & fall claims, the possible genesis for those claims was discussed with the insured and corrective steps explored in response. Aspen’s proactive management of the account and working relationship with its principals led the organization to make changes that not only lowered the company’s exposures, but also kept patrons safer.

SponsoredContent_Aspen

World-class claims management

Despite expert planning and careful prevention, losses and claims are inevitable. With Aspen’s claims department involved from the earliest stages of risk assessment, the department has developed world-class claims-processing capability.

“When a claim does arrive, everyone knows exactly how to operate,” said Perrella. “By understanding the perspectives of both the underwriters and the actuaries, our claims folks have grown to be better business people.

“We have dramatically reduced the potential for any problematic communication breakdown between our claims team, broker and the client,” said Perrella.
SponsoredContent_AspenSponsoredContent_AspenA fire ripped through an office building rendering it unusable by its seven tenants. An investigation revealed that an employee of the client intentionally set the fire. The client had not purchased business interruption insurance, and instead only had coverage for the physical damage to the building.

The Aspen claims team researched a way to assist the client in filing a third-party claim through secondary insurance that covered the business interruption portion of the loss. The attention, knowledge and creativity of the claims team saved the client from possible insurmountable losses.

SponsoredContent_Aspen

Modernize your carrier relationship

Aspen Insurance’s claims philosophy is a great example of how this carrier’s innovative perspective is redefining the underwriter-client relationship. Learn more about how Aspen Insurance can benefit your risk management program at http://www.aspen.co/insurance/.

Stephen Perrella, Senior Vice President, Casualty, can be reached at Stephen.perrella@aspen-insurance.com.

This article is provided for news and information purposes only and does not necessarily represent Aspen’s views and does constitute legal advice. This article reflects the opinion of the author at the time it was written taking into account market, regulatory and other conditions at the time of writing which may change over time. Aspen does not undertake a duty to update the article.

SponsoredContent
BrandStudioLogo

This article was produced by the R&I Brand Studio, a unit of the advertising department of Risk & Insurance, in collaboration with Aspen Insurance. The editorial staff of Risk & Insurance had no role in its preparation.




Aspen Insurance is a business segment of Aspen Insurance Holdings Limited. It provides insurance for property, casualty, marine, energy and transportation, financial and professional lines, and programs business.
Share this article: