Email
Newsletters
R&I ONE®
(weekly)
The best articles from around the web and R&I, handpicked by R&I editors.
WORKERSCOMP FORUM
(weekly)
Workers' Comp news and insights as well as columns and features from R&I.
RISK SCENARIOS
(monthly)
Update on new scenarios as well as upcoming Risk Scenarios Live! events.

Adjuster X

Citizen Kane

By: | March 3, 2014 • 3 min read
This column is based on the experiences of a group of long-time claims adjusters. The situations they describe are real, but the names and key details are kept confidential. Michelle Kerr is the editor of this column and can be reached at mkerr@lrp.com.

Cynthia Kane, 58, allegedly suffered shortness of breath due to breathing in petroleum fumes over a prolonged period. Kane had already “lawyered up,” so a statement was out of the question. Her file during her 15 years with Union Manufacturing raised no suspicions. Kane was a nonsmoker, and she had never complained to the company nurse about pulmonary problems.

I arranged to tour Kane’s work location. It was separated from the machine shop, where the actual manufacturing took place, by a floor-to-ceiling wall with glass windows. The assembly area was not particularly dirty, and I verified that the HVAC system was up to specifications and maintained twice annually.

Advertisement




Kane didn’t appear to be in any distress as she did her job.

Kane’s shift ended at 5 p.m., so I returned to the plant at 4:45 that afternoon and waited in the parking lot. I followed her as she made her way home in a fairly new two-door sports car. She stopped at a dry cleaner on the way. I parked and waited nearby for 10 minutes. When she didn’t come out, I decided to
go in.

This was a large operation with the cleaning machines in the back room. There were huge fans throughout the store, but even so there was an unmistakable kerosene-like smell from the solvents used in the dry cleaning process.

At the counter, I asked the clerk about dry-cleaning bedspreads while I strained to see into the back of the store. It was evident Kane was working.

I scratched my head. Why didn’t her attorneys name the shop as a co-defendant on the claims petition? It had far greater pulmonary exposure to airborne contaminants than Union Manufacturing.

The next day, I went back to the dry cleaner and asked to speak with Kane. The flustered counter person said they had no employee by that name. I went back to the dry cleaners three more times during the next two weeks, and each time, I saw Kane’s car there.

I arranged to have a disability evaluation by a pulmonologist, who confirmed that Kane had a mild pulmonary disability (5 percent PPD rating). After reading my report, the doctor concluded the condition was not due to her work at Union Manufacturing. Kane’s attorney had a disability report rating Kane at 25 percent PPD.

I couldn’t fault Kane for wanting a part-time job to help pay for living expenses (and her sports car), but she left me no choice but to deny the claim against Union.

I called her counsel and explained that we’d have to go to trial. He was incredulous, until I explained my findings.

Advertisement




“Your client didn’t tell you about her ‘under the table’ deal at Salerno’s Dry Cleaning, did she?” I asked him. “I personally observed her working there on three different occasions, and noted the smell of the dry cleaning solvent was very strong.

“I am willing to bet that exposure is the proximate cause of any pulmonary disability she has, rather than from a clean and temperature-controlled environment at Union Manufacturing Co. My examining physician agrees.”

The attorney reluctantly agreed to withdraw the petition. Kane continued to work at Union, and whether she kept her night job at the dry cleaner wasn’t my concern. A good investigation paid off and the claim against Union Manufacturing hit a snag.

Share this article:

Ebola in the Workplace

Ebola’s Impact on the Health Care Industry

Though risk to US health care workers remains low, an Ebola outbreak could pose a workers’ comp risk to the industry.
By: | October 17, 2014 • 6 min read
Ebola

Now that a second nurse at Texas Presbyterian Hospital in Dallas has been infected with the Ebola virus, the risk to U.S. health care workers has been thrown into the limelight.

“Health care workers are at more risk than any other worker,” said Ron Leopold, M.D., health outcomes practice leader for Willis North America. “But I think there is an overwhelming tendency for all of us and the national media to overblow the risk.”

The virus is highly contagious, but only through direct contact with an infected person. “That’s a very small number of health care workers in this country,” he said. “Being alerted to what’s going on but not alarmed is critical.”

“Being alerted to what’s going on but not alarmed is critical.” — Dr. Ron Leopold, health outcomes practice leader, Willis North America

However, as more doctors, nurses and other clinical staff are exposed to the virus, the potential spread of Ebola on U.S. soil could pose a considerable workers’ comp risk for the health care industry.

“What if doctors treating patients in the U.S. are exposed? For every doctor, you have multiple staff working beneath them. That could have a quick and dramatic effect on personnel at the hospital and the financial consequence would be large,” said Pete Reilly, health care practice leader at retail broker William Gallagher Associates.

Advertisement




In the case of nurses Nina Pham and Amber Joy Vinson, who both cared for Liberian Ebola patient Thomas Duncan at Texas Health Presbyterian Hospital in Dallas and subsequently contracted the disease, illness clearly arose out of the course and scope of employment.

Arguments could be made that breaches in safety protocol led to their exposure, placing fault on the nurses and precluding coverage. But given the CDC’s admission of mishandling its approach to Ebola safety training and not offering enough assistance to the hospital, that rationale may not stand up.

At a hearing of the House Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations, CDC director Thomas Frieden even said, “While we do not yet know exactly how these transmissions occurred, they demonstrate the need to strengthen the procedures for infection-control protocols which allowed for exposure to the virus.”

Several of the nurses’ co-workers also said that they followed CDC guidelines and wore full hazmat gear while caring for Duncan.

“There are details about every case that would come to bear, but it all depends on the carrier, the policy and other things we can’t address until a scenario is presented,” said Eric Justin, M.D., chief medical officer at Lockton Cos.

Workers’ comp carrier and large health systems, which are typically self-insured, simply don’t have enough information to determine coverage at this point.

It’s tough to understand what all the risks are at this point.”– Dr. Eric Justin, chief medical officer, Lockton Cos.

“It’s a small numbers problem. It’s tough to understand what all the risks are at this point,” Justin said.

Even if few health care workers become infected, the impact on workers’ comp could be significant for any individual hospital because of the high costs associated with caring for a patient in isolation.

“You may not have to close or quarantine your emergency room, but certainly you’ve had to quadruple your order for some type of vaccine or other medications,” Reilly said. Additional expenses may be incurred for hazmat suits, the proper disposal of those suits, additional steps needed for disinfection of hospital rooms and equipment, and even public relations messaging that may be necessary to reassure the public that a facility is safe.

“Normal business services may be 50 percent more expense in this type of situation because you have to go through additional steps to comply with CDC protocol,” Reilly said.

It’s up to hospital risk managers to plan for the admission of Ebola patient, however unlikely, to ensure staff is up to date on safety protocols.

CDC Guidelines

The transmission of the disease on U.S. soil has sparked renewed vigor from the CDC, including clearer and more rigorous guidelines for the proper wear and removal of protective gear, and a plan to send larger, more experienced teams of experts to any hospital caring for an Ebola patient.

Advertisement




Initially, the CDC indicated that any hospital in the U.S. should have the essentials to treat Ebola on their own. The experiences of Emory Hospital in Atlanta and then Texas Presbyterian prove that assumption to be naïve and unsafe.

“In a very short time, mostly due to the situation in Dallas, we’re learning [about the virus] rather rapidly, and one sign of that learning is that the CDC announced that they will start to be much more assertive about providing not just teams to go wherever an Ebola case is confirmed, but larger teams that are experienced not just with working with Ebola but also training others to work with the isolation gear and decontamination procedures,” Justin said.

Most doctors and nurses are aware of the guidelines issued by the CDC and OSHA regarding protective gear, but many have likely not practiced them since early days of job training.

“Even people with experience are finding, ‘This isn’t so easy,’” Justin said. “They’re becoming aware of the need to actually practice them.”

Current CDC protocol also calls for any worker to be observed while removing protective gowns, masks and gloves to ensure that everything is done correctly.

Justin called this “buddy system approach” a necessary methodological step, which allows observers to both step in in a critical moment to correct a problem, and also record information to suggest process changes in the future.

The CDC has also backtracked on earlier assertions that any hospital can handle an isolation patient.

Future cases will most likely end up in one of the four larger, specialized centers that house their own biocontainment units, including Nebraska Medical Center in Omaha, the National Institutes of Health in Bethseda, Md., and St. Patrick Hospital in Missoula, Mont., along with Emory Hospital.

Third-Party Relationships

Health care risk managers should make sure to keep third party service providers informed about Ebola response plans and safety procedures.

The experience at Emory, the first U.S hospital to receive an Ebola patient, revealed shortcomings in the U.S.’s plan to manage the virus.

Several third-party vendors working with the hospital balked at the idea of dealing with any potentially infected materials.

Their waste removal company, for example, refused to haul away the high volume of waste generated by someone afflicted by the disease. A transport company would not take blood samples a few blocks away to be tested.

Advertisement




“People on the waste management side are a step or two removed from the clinical setting, so I can see why they’d be concerned,” Justin said. “The best thing to do to allay those anxieties is to have discussions between infection control and those companies, and also let them know of the procedures available.”

Having these third-party vendors on board not only help care for an infectious patient run more smoothly, but also mitigates the risk of a contracted worker making claims of negligence against a hospital.

“As part of your disaster recovery plan, you should be checking with those vendors and making sure they are going to respond,” said Deana Allen, SVP at Willis North America’s national health care practice. “These are the critical services we’ll need.”

Katie Siegel is a staff writer at Risk & Insurance®. She can be reached at ksiegel@lrp.com.
Share this article:

Sponsored: Helmsman Management Services

Six Best Practices For Effective WC Management

An ever-changing healthcare landscape keeps workers comp managers on their toes.
By: | October 15, 2014 • 5 min read

It’s no secret that the professionals responsible for managing workers compensation programs need to be constantly vigilant.

Rising health care costs, complex state regulation, opioid-based prescription drug use and other scary trends tend to keep workers comp managers awake at night.

“Risk managers can never be comfortable because it’s the nature of the beast,” said Debbie Michel, president of Helmsman Management Services LLC, a third-party claims administrator (and a subsidiary of Liberty Mutual Insurance). “To manage comp requires a laser-like, constant focus on following best practices across the continuum.”

Michel pointed to two notable industry trends — rises in loss severity and overall medical spending — that will combine to drive comp costs higher. For example, loss severity is predicted to increase in 2014-2015, mainly due to those rising medical costs.

Debbie discusses the top workers’ comp challenge facing buyers and brokers.

The nation’s annual medical spending, for its part, is expected to grow 6.1 percent in 2014 and 6.2 percent on average from 2015 through 2022, according to the Federal Government’s Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. This increase is expected to be driven partially by increased medical services demand among the nation’s aging population – many of whom are baby boomers who have remained in the workplace longer.

Other emerging trends also can have a potential negative impact on comp costs. For example, the recent classification of obesity as a disease (and the corresponding rise of obesity in the U.S.) may increase both workers comp claim frequency and severity.

SponsoredContent_LM“The true goal here is to think about injured employees. Everyone needs to focus on helping them get well, back to work and functioning at their best. At the same time, following a best practices approach can reduce overall comp costs, and help risk managers get a much better night’s sleep.”
– Debbie Michel, President, Helmsman Management Services LLC (a subsidiary of Liberty Mutual)

“These are just some factors affecting the workers compensation loss dollar,” she added. “Risk managers, working with their TPAs and carriers, must focus on constant improvement. The good news is there are proven best practices to make it happen.”

Michel outlined some of those best practices risk managers can take to ensure they get the most value from their workers comp spending and help their employees receive the best possible medical outcomes:

Pre-Loss

1. Workplace Partnering

Risk managers should look to partner with workplace wellness/health programs. While typically managed by different departments, there is an obvious need for risk management and health and wellness programs to be aligned in understanding workforce demographics, health patterns and other claim red flags. These are the factors that often drive claims or impede recovery.

“A workforce might have a higher percentage of smokers or diabetics than the norm, something you can learn from health and wellness programs. Comp managers can collaborate with health and wellness programs to help mitigate the potential impact,” Michel said, adding that there needs to be a direct line between the workers compensation goals and overall employee health and wellness goals.

Debbie discusses the second biggest challenge facing buyers and brokers.

2. Financing Alternatives

Risk managers must constantly re-evaluate how they finance workers compensation insurance programs. For example, there could be an opportunity to reduce costs by moving to higher retention or deductible levels, or creating a captive. Taking on a larger financial, more direct stake in a workers comp program can drive positive changes in safety and related areas.

“We saw this trend grow in 2012-2013 during comp rate increases,” Michel said. “When you have something to lose, you naturally are more focused on safety and other pre-loss issues.”

3. TPA Training, Tenure and Resources

Businesses need to look for a tailored relationship with their TPA or carrier, where they work together to identify and build positive, strategic workers compensation programs. Also, they must exercise due diligence when choosing a TPA by taking a hard look at its training, experience and tools, which ultimately drive program performance.

For instance, Michel said, does the TPA hold regular monthly or quarterly meetings with clients and brokers to gauge progress or address issues? Or, does the TPA help create specific initiatives in a quest to take the workers compensation program to a higher level?

Post-Loss

4. Analytics to Drive Positive Outcomes, Lower Loss Costs

Michel explained that best practices for an effective comp claims management process involve taking advantage of today’s powerful analytics tools, especially sophisticated predictive modeling. When woven into an overall claims management strategy, analytics can pinpoint where to focus resources on a high-cost claim, or they can capture the best data to be used for future safety and accident prevention efforts.

“Big data and advanced analytics drive a better understanding of the claims process to bring down the total cost of risk,” Michel added.

5. Provider Network Reach, Collaboration

Risk managers must pay close attention to provider networks and specifically work with outcome-based networks – in those states that allow employers to direct the care of injured workers. Such providers understand workers compensation and how to achieve optimal outcomes.

Risk managers should also understand if and how the TPA interacts with treating physicians. For example, Helmsman offers a peer-to-peer process with its 10 regional medical directors (one in each claims office). While the medical directors work closely with claims case professionals, they also interact directly, “peer-to-peer,” with treatment providers to create effective care paths or considerations.

“We have seen a lot of value here for our clients,” Michel said. “It’s a true differentiator.”

6. Strategic Outlook

Most of all, Michel said, it’s important for risk managers, brokers and TPAs to think strategically – from pre-loss and prevention to a claims process that delivers the best possible outcome for injured workers.

Debbie explains the value of working with Helmsman Management Services.

Helmsman, which provides claims management, managed care and risk control solutions for businesses with 50 employees or more, offers clients what it calls the Account Management Stewardship Program. The program coordinates the “right” resources within an organization and brings together all critical players – risk manager, safety and claims professionals, broker, account manager, etc. The program also frequently utilizes subject matter experts (pharma, networks, nurses, etc.) to help increase knowledge levels for risk and safety managers.

“The true goal here is to think about injured employees,” Michel said. “Everyone needs to focus on helping them get well, back to work and functioning at their best.

“At the same time, following a best practices approach can reduce overall comp costs, and help risk managers get a much better night’s sleep,” she said.

To learn more about how a third-party administrator like Helmsman Management Services LLC (a subsidiary of Liberty Mutual) can help manage your workers compensation costs, contact your broker.

Email Debbie Michel

Visit Helmsman’s website

@HelmsmanTPA Twitter

Additional Insights 

Debbie discusses how Helmsman drives outcomes for risk managers.

Debbie explains how to manage medical outcomes.

Debbie discusses considerations when selecting a TPA.

SponsoredContent

BrandStudioLogo

This article was produced by the R&I Brand Studio, a unit of the advertising department of Risk & Insurance, in collaboration with Helmsman Management Services. The editorial staff of Risk & Insurance had no role in its preparation.


Helmsman Management Services (HMS) helps better control the total cost of risk by delivering superior outcomes for workers compensation, general liability and commercial auto claims. The third party claims administrator – a wholly owned subsidiary of Liberty Mutual Insurance – delivers better outcomes by blending the strength and innovation of a major carrier with the flexibility of an independent TPA.
Share this article: